I have been thinking about making a review of this anime myself....
But now I see, there's no need to do this anymore ^^ You totally speak my mind.
I loved this anime and I think it deserves this good rating. I loved the characters, especially Kuea ^^

I just played the game and I simply loved it....
And I have to admit, that I don't understand your review. To take the soundtrack for example you say it is cool and have nothing to complain about it, but you give it just 8 points? And I wouldn't rate everything the same....
Anyway, nice review, even if I'd give this wonderful game at least an B+ if not even more points....

I think you are right with your comments. The story really isn't that.... good. But the art and the music are really outstanding. I think they should at least get an B and what is wrong with the presentation?
I can see that you really looked forward and were quite disappointed in seeing this movie, weren't you?
In my opinion 4 is a bit harsh, but nonetheless good review ^^